How index providers make money: the SPY license fee, line by line
SPY paid S&P $186 million in index license fees in fiscal 2025, 32% of its costs. What index providers earn per ETF dollar, from SEC filings.
Not investment advice. Read the full disclaimer.
Short answer: Index providers earn most of their ETF money as a percentage of the assets that track their indexes. The clearest public example is SPY, the oldest US-listed ETF. In the fiscal year to September 2025, SPY paid S&P Dow Jones Indices $186.1 million in license fees. That was 31.8% of everything the fund spent. Out of every $9.45 a SPY investor pays per $10,000 per year, about $3 goes to the index provider.
Most ETFs do not disclose their license fee. SPY does, because the trust pays the fee itself and reports it as a separate line in its financial statements. That makes it the best available window into a business that is otherwise mostly hidden inside expense ratios.
How much does SPY pay S&P for the index?
SPY’s prospectus describes the deal in one sentence. The trust reimburses its sponsor, PDR Services LLC, for fees paid to S&P under the license agreement: 0.03% of the daily size of the trust, plus $600,000 a year. The sponsor passes this through; the trust, and therefore its investors, bear the cost.
At SPY’s size, the fixed $600,000 hardly matters. The variable part does. The fee rises and falls with the fund’s assets, whether or not the work of calculating the S&P 500 changes.
SPY’s expenses, fiscal year 2025
From the statement of operations for the year ended 30 September 2025:
| Expense | Amount | Share of total |
|---|---|---|
| Trustee (State Street Global Advisors Trust Company) | $304,426,733 | 52.1% |
| S&P license fee | $186,125,603 | 31.8% |
| Marketing | $81,841,111 | 14.0% |
| Registration, legal, audit, other | $12,012,209 | 2.1% |
| Total expenses | $584,405,656 | 100% |
Net assets were $680.3 billion at the end of the period, up from $589.7 billion a year earlier. The stated expense ratio is 0.0945%.
As a plausibility check: the average of the two year-end asset figures is about $635 billion. Subtracting the fixed $600,000 and dividing the rest of the license fee by that average gives 2.9 basis points, close to the contractual 3. (Our calculation. The contract uses daily values, so a two-point average can only approximate it.)
The share stays the same as the fund grows
SPY’s figures for the last four fiscal years:
| Fiscal year (to 30 Sep) | S&P license fee | Total expenses | License share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | $117,918,485 | $369,553,236 | 31.9% |
| 2023 | $115,509,122 | $361,963,739 | 31.9% |
| 2024 | $150,726,719 | $472,893,995 | 31.9% |
| 2025 | $186,125,603 | $584,405,656 | 31.8% |
The license fee grew 58% between 2022 and 2025. Its share of costs did not move, because both the trustee fee and the license fee are tied to assets. (Shares: our calculation from the filings. Data: CSV.)
Is SPY typical?
SPY is an old contract, and newer, cheaper S&P 500 ETFs from other issuers do not publish their terms. The best broad evidence comes from an academic study.
Yu An, Matteo Benetton and Yang Song analysed US equity ETFs from 2010 to 2019 (Journal of Financial Economics, 2023). Their findings:
- More than 95% of license fees in their sample were charged as a percentage of assets.
- License fees made up about one third of ETF expense ratios, rising from 31.4% in 2010 to 35.7% in 2019.
- In 2019, the average license fee was 4.4 basis points, against an estimated marginal cost of 1.6 basis points. The authors attribute about 60% of license fees to markups.
- Investors cared about which provider stood behind an index, although indexes from different providers did not produce materially different returns.
SPY’s roughly 32% share sits inside that range, which makes the fund a well-documented example of the norm.
The market: three providers, most of the revenue
According to the research firm Burton-Taylor, index providers earned a record $7.2 billion in 2025. S&P Dow Jones Indices took $1.85 billion, MSCI $1.79 billion and FTSE Russell $1.29 billion. Together that is about 68% of the total (our calculation). Alex Matturri, a former CEO of S&P Dow Jones Indices, describes indexing as a two-tier market: the three large providers collect fees on established benchmarks, while smaller ones compete with new products.
How much does MSCI earn from ETFs tracking its indexes?
MSCI is listed and reports its index business separately. In the third quarter of 2026:
- The index segment had revenue of $532.6 million.
- Of that, $269.5 million came from recurring subscriptions: data, benchmark licenses for active managers and similar.
- $246.6 million came from asset-based fees, up 24.9% on the year.
- The segment’s adjusted EBITDA margin was 77.4%.
- ETFs linked to MSCI equity indexes held $2,905 billion at quarter end.
MSCI states an average fee of 2.28 basis points, about 2.3, on those ETF assets, based on the run rate at 30 September 2026.
For an investor, that is about $2.28 a year per $10,000 in an ETF that tracks an MSCI index. That figure is an average across all MSCI-linked ETFs. The fee in any single contract, for example for a specific MSCI World ETF, is not published. (Translation into investor terms: our calculation.)
Two ways to price an index
Not every provider charges per dollar. Solactive, a Frankfurt-based provider, licenses standard benchmarks for a flat fee, regardless of fund size. According to Solactive’s chief markets officer Timo Pfeiffer, prices for a plain market-cap-weighted ETF with an expense ratio around 5 basis points start at about $10,000 a year. More complex indexes, such as ESG variants, can add a fee of 2 to 3 basis points.
The difference becomes visible at scale. For a hypothetical fund with $1 billion in assets:
| Pricing model | Annual license cost |
|---|---|
| 4.4 basis points (2019 average, An/Benetton/Song) | $440,000 |
| 2.28 basis points (MSCI ETF average, Q3 2026) | $228,000 |
| Flat fee from about $10,000 (Solactive entry price) | about $10,000 |
(Illustration, our calculation. Real contracts are negotiated, and the flat fee for a fund of this size may be higher than the entry price.)
Switching is possible, and has happened
In October 2012, Vanguard announced that 22 index funds with about $537 billion in assets would move from MSCI benchmarks to indexes from FTSE (six international funds) and CRSP, a research centre at the University of Chicago (16 US funds). The company named lower licensing costs as the reason and said the new long-term contracts would provide cost certainty. The transition was completed in mid-2013.
European ETF issuers have made similar moves since, from MSCI to near-identical indexes from Solactive or FTSE (examples collected by etf.capital). They will be the subject of a separate article.
What this means if you hold an index ETF
Method and data
All figures for SPY come from the fund’s financial statements in its annual SEC registration filings. Shares, averages and the per-$10,000 figures are our own calculations; the CSV file contains the raw values. Figures for MSCI are taken from its Q3 2026 earnings release and quarterly report.
This article is based on research in public sources. Corrections, additional information and responses from the companies named are very welcome; contact details are in the imprint. Corrections will be listed at the top of this article.