Why challengers to MSCI and S&P usually fail, and why Solactive didn't

Most challengers to MSCI and S&P failed: free indexes, Wilshire, cloud start-ups. Why Solactive and CRSP won, and what it took. Sourced, with figures.

By · Published

Not investment advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Short answer: Over the past fifteen years, at least half a dozen firms have tried to break the hold of MSCI, S&P Dow Jones Indices and FTSE Russell. Some gave their indexes away, one carried the oldest name in US indexing, others built faster technology. Most of them did not take a large benchmark from the big three on their own. The ones that grew did so in one of three ways: a large fund company moved its assets to them, they became suppliers to exchanges and incumbents, or, in the case of Solactive, they sold cheap standard indexes to issuers who brought their own investors.

It also matters which market you look at. The best-known flagships, the S&P 500 and the MSCI World, are a US index and a developed-markets index. For ETFs on the whole world, the picture looks different.

This article sorts the attempts by strategy. It relies on company announcements and trade press; our own conclusions are marked.

Why didn’t free indexes catch on?

Freedom Index Company. A UK not-for-profit, launched in 2012 to offer free, independent indexes. By 2016 it covered the top 50 to 1,000 US- and UK-listed stocks plus South African top 50 and 100, funded by donations from industry participants, and was asking for more. We found no later reports on the company, and none on funds tracking its indexes.

Morningstar Open Indexes Project. Launched in late 2016, it offered a subset of Morningstar’s global equity indexes “for general benchmarking purposes at no cost.” Morningstar’s head of indexes, Sanjay Arya, framed it as a response to costs: many investment managers reported that benchmark data fees had doubled or tripled over five years. Free meant free for measuring performance. Using an index for an ETF or a derivative still required a paid licence.

Euronext. In June 2016, the exchange operator announced an “open-source” family of European indexes that would be fee-free for clients who used them as the basis for new investment products, with a launch planned for the end of that year. Michael Hodgson, then head of information services, argued that rising licence and data fees were not meeting client needs. Euronext later listed two Morningstar blue-chip indexes in 2017 and launched futures on them. We found no later reports of a broad fee-free index family in use.

Strategy 2: an old name with new partners

The Wilshire 5000 dates back to the 1970s and was one of the first measures of the entire US stock market. Vanguard’s Total Stock Market Index Fund tracked it, as the Dow Jones Wilshire 5000, until April 2005; the fund then moved to MSCI, and in June 2013 to CRSP.

In February 2021, Wilshire and the Financial Times announced a collaboration, and in June 2021 the index was relaunched as the FT Wilshire 5000. At the launch, FT chief executive John Ridding called it “a significant first step in building a global index business.” In March 2023, Wilshire moved its index business into a separate company, Wilshire Indexes, with the FT and Singapore Exchange as strategic partners; the FT became a shareholder.

Less than three years later, in early 2026, it was over. The UK operating companies went into administration and staff were laid off at the end of February. TMX VettaFi bought the infrastructure indexes, ISS STOXX bought the custom index platform W+, and the Wilshire 5000 went back to the parent’s asset management arm. WatersTechnology described the venture as loss-making.

What price can do

Price matters when an issuer already has the assets and wants to reduce its costs.

In October 2012, Vanguard announced that 22 index funds with about $537 billion in assets would move from MSCI to FTSE (six international funds) and to CRSP, a research centre at the University of Chicago (16 US funds). Vanguard named lower licensing costs as the reason: its chief investment officer Gus Sauter said the company had “negotiated licensing agreements” that it expected would lower expenses for fund shareholders. European ETF issuers have made similar moves since, from MSCI to near-identical indexes from Solactive or FTSE.

Two markets: flagship brands and world indexes

MSCI and S&P built their reputations on indexes that cover part of the world: the S&P 500 covers US large caps, the MSCI World covers developed markets only. Both providers also offer global indexes, but the index that dominates all-world ETFs in Europe comes from FTSE Russell. The Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF is, according to Vanguard, Europe’s largest FTSE All-World ETF, with $76.8 billion in assets in July 2026.

All-world ETFs are where issuers now compete hardest on price. Vanguard cut the fund’s ongoing charge from 0.22% to 0.19% in October 2025 and to 0.14% in July 2026. Jon Cleborne, head of Vanguard Europe, said the cuts would “help investors keep more of their returns.” Even after the second cut, its two closest competitors in the FTSE All-World segment were cheaper at 0.12%, according to Börse Express. Amundi launched its Prime All Country World UCITS ETF in early 2024 with a management fee of 0.07%, at the time the lowest for an all-country ETF in Europe according to Amundi. The fund does not track an MSCI or FTSE index. It tracks the Solactive GBS Global Markets Large & Mid Cap Index, which covers about the largest 85% of free-float market capitalisation in developed and emerging markets. Its accumulating US dollar share class alone held $2.1 billion in October 2024 and $4.6 billion at the end of January 2026, according to Amundi’s factsheets.

How did Solactive succeed where others failed?

Solactive was founded in Frankfurt in 2007. Its business model differs from the big three in two ways.

First, it prices differently. Besides volume-based licence fees, Solactive offers a flat-fee model, as its own annual report states; according to its chief markets officer, prices for a simple market-cap ETF start at about $10,000 a year (see How index providers make money).

Second, it works largely in the background. Solactive builds and calculates indexes for issuers who sell the funds under their own brands. In 2018 it launched its own Global Benchmark Series, which now underlies the Amundi Prime range. According to ETF.com, Solactive is also the largest index partner of the US issuer Global X, at 42% of that issuer’s assets, although its name rarely appears in the fund names.

The company looks stable from the outside. In 2020, its revenue rose 16.6% to €35.7 million, with 189 employees at year end and a small net loss of €1.6 million, according to the annual report published in the German company register. The majority shareholder was Bullseye GmbH, Frankfurt. Summit Partners, a growth equity firm, later made a €50 million minority investment; at that time, Solactive reported more than $200 billion in assets linked to more than 17,000 of its indexes.

Strategy 3: build better technology, then become a supplier

Around 2019 and 2020, a wave of start-ups promised cloud-based, faster and cheaper index calculation: BITA in Frankfurt, MerQube in the US, Index One, Moorgate Benchmarks and others. Several of them still exist. What changed is who they work for.

Company Started as What happened
BITA (Frankfurt) Cloud platform for self-indexing Strategic investment by SIX, the Swiss exchange group, in March 2024
MerQube (US) Cloud-native index provider, launched 2019 Series A led by J.P. Morgan; its best-known index, the US Tech+ Vol Advantage Index, is licensed exclusively to J.P. Morgan, which also holds a stake. Series C in April 2026 with Deutsche Börse among the investors. Describes itself as the leading provider for defined outcome ETF indexes
Ultumus (London) ETF and index data Acquired by SIX in 2021
Moorgate Benchmarks European index administrator Acquired by Morningstar in 2021
ROBO Global, EQM Indexes, iNDEX Research Thematic and custom indexes All acquired by TMX VettaFi, owned by the Toronto exchange group, between April 2023 and October 2024

The challengers moved into complex niches such as options-based strategies, structured products and custom indexes; their owners or investors are now exchange groups and large banks. Alex Matturri, a former CEO of S&P Dow Jones Indices, calls indexing a two-tier market; the newcomers settled in the second tier.

The non-profit that won, and what happened next

The most successful challenger of the past fifteen years was a university research centre.

CRSP, founded at the University of Chicago in 1960, had built historical stock market data for academic research. Vanguard’s 2012 switch made its indexes the benchmarks for some of the largest index funds in the world, including the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund. By 2025, CRSP’s indexes were benchmarks for more than $3 trillion in US equities, on annual revenue of about $55 million.

In September 2025, Morningstar agreed to buy CRSP from the University of Chicago for $375 million. The deal closed on 2 February 2026 at about $365 million. Morningstar extended Vanguard’s use of the indexes and announced that the CRSP indexes will be rebranded under the Morningstar name. In its announcement, Morningstar said the deal furthers its efforts “to disrupt the costly, entrenched index industry.”

The fixed cost of being allowed to exist

Since 2018, the EU Benchmarks Regulation requires index providers whose benchmarks are used in EU financial products to be authorised or registered as benchmark administrators, with governance, oversight and complaints handling. In 2016, Morningstar’s Arya expected the regulation to drive consolidation and higher fees, because compliance costs would rise. He also cited figures from the Financial Times: 53% of European mutual fund assets were benchmarked against five index providers, and in the US, 73% against three.

What the pattern says

For investors, the consequence is practical. In all-world ETFs, competition between index providers is real, and it shows up in falling fees. Among the flagship indexes, concentration has lasted through a decade of challengers. Whether a different model could work, for example a non-profit index with a binding ownership structure and a committed issuer from day one, is a question we will come back to.

About this article

The statements in this article are based on research in public sources: company announcements, regulatory documents and trade press. We have not spoken to the companies named. We are very interested in corrections, additional information and responses from the companies and people involved; contact details are in the imprint. Corrections will be listed at the top of this article.